Beck’s friends are chaos, Peach is spiraling, and Joe’s still out here trying to justify murder with poetry. Welcome to the midpoint of You Season 1 — where we officially trust no one.

Previously On ‘You’

Joe Goldberg, your neighborhood bookstore stalker, has been inching his way into Beck’s life, all while harboring his own dark secrets. As we dig deeper, Peach’s obsessive tendencies and Beck’s cluelessness are becoming more apparent. Meanwhile, Joe’s attempts to show love through manipulation and violence are only escalating. Who will be left standing by the end?

Episode 5 – “Rock Bottom”

Joe’s attempt to take out Peach is a comedy of errors. Not only does he fail to execute his plan with any level of skill, but he also proves just how unprepared he is for the consequences of his actions. It’s almost as if he’s still learning the basics of being a psychopath.

Deeper Dive into the Characters

• Anika: Beck’s “fat racist friend” is the type of person who shows her true colors when it matters most. She’s rude, judgmental, and downright toxic — a prime example of the kind of energy Beck is allowing to be part of her life. Anika represents the shallow friendship dynamic in Beck’s world, where people seem to be more about their own drama than supporting each other.
• Peach: Ah, Peach. The queen of obsession. Peach’s behavior is classic stalker material, and it becomes clear she’s not only threatened by Joe’s presence in Beck’s life, but also by Beck’s own sense of independence. Peach manipulates Beck with toxic displays of vulnerability, even using her own suicidal threats to keep Beck close. It’s a controlling, possessive love that sets the tone for the rest of the season. No one can be that obsessed without something seriously wrong underneath the surface. Peach, meanwhile, serves as the perfect foil to Joe’s obsession: while Joe’s creeping is framed as a twisted form of love, Peach’s obsession is just pure control.
• Beck: The ultimate damsel in distress. Beck is undeniably a flawed character, but it’s hard not to feel a little sympathy for her. She’s been raised in an environment that values superficial relationships, and her inability to recognize how toxic her friendships (and her relationship with Joe) are speaks volumes about her lack of self-awareness. She’s easily manipulated by both Joe and Peach, and yet she seems to believe she’s in control of the situation. Her self-destructive tendencies play out in dramatic ways, making her the perfect target for the manipulative people around her.

Becky’s Take on the Characters:

• Peach: “Could do with a good slap.”
• Anika & Beck: “They need better friends.”
• Beck: “Needs to open her eyes to what’s really going on.”
• Joe: “Should’ve stepped in next door, maybe avoided the ass-kicking by Paco’s stepdad.”

Episode 6 – “House of Horrors”

Joe takes another step into madness, hiding in Peach’s home as if he were auditioning for Big Brother: Stalker Edition. The tension is palpable as he’s this close to being caught, but the question on our minds is: who’s going to be the one to die?

Peach’s tragic fate feels inevitable. In a twisted way, we’re almost relieved for her; she was spinning out of control and couldn’t find a way out. Becky’s thoughts on the murder? “She got what she deserved.” Harsh, maybe, but considering the emotional torment Peach put Beck through, it’s almost a fitting end. While Joe’s behavior is equally obsessive, there’s a strange justification in his mind, which is, of course, what makes him such a compelling (if toxic) character.

Deeper Dive Into Joe’s Complex Mind:

• Joe Goldberg: Joe’s psyche is a complicated mess of moral contradictions. He justifies his stalking and murder as “love,” but it’s all a twisted attempt to manipulate people into his vision of a perfect life. His interactions with Beck are anything but normal; they’re toxic, dangerous, and borderline delusional. When he sneaks around Peach’s house, hoping to get away with murder, it shows how much he craves control. Joe thrives on creating a narrative that revolves around his idea of love, even if it’s founded on lies and violence. And yet, we’re still drawn to him, questioning whether he’s a victim of circumstance or simply a villain in disguise.

🛠️ Joe Logic Translator: “If I ignore domestic violence to stalk my girlfriend’s friend… that’s what love looks like, right?”

Final Thoughts on Episodes 5 & 6

The tension of these two episodes feels like a simmering pot about to boil over. We see the complex layers of each character, from Peach’s obsessive love to Beck’s naïve trust, and Joe’s pathological need for control. Episode 6 is the turning point, and we’re left hanging on the edge of our seats, wondering who will be left standing at the end.

At this stage, it’s clear that Joe’s motivations and behavior aren’t going to stop — he’s only getting worse. But can Beck wake up before it’s too late? Can she learn to see the real Joe, or will she remain stuck in her delusion of a perfect romance?

🎯 Becky’s Slap List: Peach… again. For the third time.

📺 Streaming Now:

Catch You Season 1 on Netflix, where Joe Goldberg continues to charm, stalk, and do anything for love — even murder.

📅 Final Thoughts

Six episodes in, and the show’s moral compass is flipping all over the place. Joe’s logic? Flawed. Beck’s judgment? Nonexistent. Peach? Gone. But we’re still hooked, and that’s the magic of You. We’re aiming to continue with two episodes a night, and we know the chaos is only going to escalate from here.

Until next time — keep your friends close, and your bookstore stalkers closer.